Posted on 07-12-2009
Filed Under (Sports) by Rashtrakut

Its that time of the year again.  When the traditional American meritocratic process falls sway to the blind appeal of tradition.  When the BCS Cartel starts spinning reasons why the atrocity of a post season is justified behind pointless slogans like “Its all for the student athlete” “In the current system every game is a playoff”  “The tradition of the bowls are essential to college football” “There is no way to devise a playoff that will satisfy everybody”  Concerned with fan unrest that shows over 80% of the fan base disliking the current system, the cartel hired former White House spokesman Ari Fleischer to peddle the increasingly laughable talking points for the current system.

After the last three seasons it is laughable to suggest that the virtue of the current system is that every game is a playoff.  Two years ago the national title game consisted of a 1 loss Ohio State team and a 2 loss LSU team (somehow more deserving than all the other 2 loss teams) both of which lost their last home game.  Last year’s title game was a match up of one loss teams (magically deemed superior to the other one loss).  Oklahoma made the title game primarily because of a 3 way tie-break that relegated a team from Austin with a castrated bovine mascot to a lot of teeth gnashing.  This year the title game participants were chosen out of FIVE unbeaten teams.  The team from Austin that whined last year got to the title game largely based on pedigree, not having beaten any team of substance this year.  Yet the argument persists and will be repeated each year.  Just tell TCU, Cincinnati and Boise State this year how every game is a playoff.

College football’s ruling chiefs made it clear how much they cared about the welfare of the student-athlete (at most of the football factories the student appellation is a bit of a joke) when they raised the regular season to 12 games.  The change allowed the larger schools to rake in more revenue with an additional home game.  Somehow college basketball and baseball seasons survive across two semesters, but a playoff induced extension of the season into early January would be unbearable to the football player ( a ridiculous argument made worse by the scheduling of the so called national title game in the second week of January).

Other than the fans of the schools participating, most fans don’t care about the proliferation of bowls featuring teams with 6-6 records.  The college basketball playoff shows just how popular a football playoff could be.  Unfortunately, it will not happen in the near future.  The real reason is one which everybody knows but will never be uttered by the BCS honchos.  Money.

A playoff would require money to be shared equally among conferences.  The current system keeps the premier bowls and as result the lions share of the bowl money with the major conferences.  Under congressional pressure, the BCS reluctantly modified its rules a few years ago to make it easier to accommodate small conference schools.  This year with Oklahoma State’s belly flop against Oklahoma, Pittsburgh’s failure to knock off Cincinnati and Nebraska’s failure to shut the door on that school in Austin they reluctantly feature two small conference schools – TCU and Boise State.

And so the cycle continues.  This rant will return next year as a meaningless venting exercise.  Half of college football will start the season knowing that even perfection will not give them a share of the national title (Utah last year and TCU/Boise State/Cincinnati this year).  Even though every other sport and every other division of football somehow manages a playoff this will somehow be impossible to structure in the top tier of college football.  So the “championship” will remain decided by generally clueless media voters and not on the field.  Cartels of the world rejoice…you have college football shackled in chains.

Subscribe to Rashtrakut by Email

Share
(1) Comment    Read More   

Comments

Ross Molho on 8 January, 2010 at 10:00 pm #

I wasn’t entirely sure who the author of this blog was until I read this post. Many people are passionate about politics, numismatics, Indian culture and more but there is only one man I know who holds all these interests along with an unbridled passion for college football.


Post a Comment
Name:
Email:
Website:
Comments: